Pitt I agree, TCU I'm curious why you think we should be out-recruiting them...
I agree TCU is certainly a trendy team and had a very successful season. However, my point was simply that if NU is going to have "top 10" type classes, eventually you have to beat quite a few good teams in the living room of the recruits. NU fans always say NU is top 10 for facilities, tradition, name recognition, etc. So I guess it depends on what you are consider makes recruiting successful. If it is a combination of tradition, name recognition, recent success, etc.....then NU would have to beat a number of teams to routinely have classes ranked as high as many expect or at least want.
Off the top of my head, these would include: OSU, Mich, MSU, PSU, Mia, FSU, Ala, Fla, LSU, Aub, A&M, Missouri, Tex, OU, Baylor, TCU, Oregon, Stanford, USC, UCLA There are 20 teams which either have quite a bit of recent success or are traditionally a name brand. If NU can't out recruit TCU or UCLA in that list, then maybe expectations should not be top 10 classes, as seems to be taken for granted by many fans. So, ultimately, it comes down to what can realistically be expected.
I understand individually players will pick what they see as the best fit for themselves.