I chewed on this all night and wanted to put together my long form post. TLDR: this is not getting better this year because the offense is horrific. Sadly the same problems we saw in the game were the same problems we saw in spring practice.
The good: Our special teams improved significantly. Our defense was solid except the front 3 rarely got a pass rush. Our offensive line seems to have improved and I would argue that two of those sacks were on Sims (remember when I posted about completion percentage being a deceptive statistic because players took unnecessary sacks when they knew that was a metric?).
The what: What ever happened to Fidone, Ervin, the use of the FB or even Chief Borders. Chief is not even on the participation report. I saw one play where we used a FB in a traditional FB role. We used a total of 18 defenders. This is no different than the Frost era. It mostly seemed like we used the same players all game.
My issues: Minnesota is not a good team. This team replaced a lot of players this year and had two of their starting LBs injured. We also took out their best DL in the 3rd quarter. Could we move the ball? Not one bit. First and foremost we had to burn 3 timeouts during the game due to procedures or not getting the play in on time. Same problems from the spring game. We turned the ball over 4 times, and our output was pathetic. Everyone is talking about Ervin's ypg. Take his long run out and he is barely hitting 4 ypc. You need consistency, not home runs. This offense is going to continue to struggle all year. We have no true possession receiver. We have no true downfield threat. We have no power running game.
Sims was horrific. Three of his completions he never actually saw the reciever and we re great catches by the wideouts. For the game Sims was 11-19 with three interceptions and 3 sacks. That means that he was truly 11-22. That is not going to beat anyone.
But the worst part of thee game (IMO) was the blown opportunity at the end of the first half. Was it a TD by Grant? Probably. But with 11 seconds left you do NOT go for it from 6 with no timeouts. Why? If you get a hold, a sack, or are stopped short, you get zero points. This is football 101. Prior to the final drive we were barely moving the ball. To ask six yards and no mistakes is a big gamble. Those lost three points came up huge. In fact, IMO this was one of the worst calls in NU history. This is worse then the SF onside kick because you can still stop the drive after the onside kick. This is just taking points off the board. Oh, and if you have not seen the score, we lost by those exact same 3 points. When asked about it Rhule said he would do that again.
Finally, I see 2 games we should win on the schedule. I see another three tossups. Beyond that, 7 consecutive losing seasons.