And that is my point.
I posted what I was being told about the staff wanting to RS one of the backs before this news came out. Typically, RBs aren't redshirted, but it make sense to RS one of these backs. And unless AT separates himself from Newby (which he has not), it makes more sense to redshirt him.
And I agree. As this has more to do with their development and ability with what they are asked to do rather than their eligibility level. Which is why I said at the beginning of post #21 "I don't think putting distance between him and Cross is as big a factor as many are making it out to be." This is in regards to Ameer being a Jr. & Cross being a Soph. vs trying to make Newby a year ahead of Taylor to even it out.