Have you ever worked for a company you thought was a fit but later found it was not the right place for you? How long should you stay before you exercise your right to find another employer?
Yes, I've been in that situation more than once. But I've always felt a commitment to my position. When I've realized it's time to find something else, I've always tried to complete my current projects, as well as putting a "turnover plan" in place for the next guy who ended up taking my job.
I realize most career situations are a bit different from a college football team. I can understand a player wanting to transfer:
- if a new coach comes in who clearly is not going to give him a chance,
- if a family emergency requires moving closer to home,
- if he's a QB way down on the depth chart, and the only way he'll ever see the field is to transfer,
- etc.
But I would be more understanding if a guy was new and didn't have any deep ties to the team, and wanted to transfer out. When you're about to be a senior, about to break all the existing records for your position, and ought to be a leader on the team, I feel that requires a deeper commitment to stick it out. Now, I don't want to judge JD's specific situation, since I have zero knowledge of what he's going through. If he's going through some mental health issues, etc. he needs to do what's best for his own health.
I'm just speaking in general terms, when I say there needs to be a stronger commitment to the TEAM from kids in general. And that philosophy extends to coaches as well. I have no respect for the Petrino / Bielema / Schnellenberger / Urban -esque method of jumping to the next rung on the ladder every time an opportunity comes up, with no consideration for the players. Respect is worthy for coaches who are committed to their players, like TO choosing not to take the CU job, and Bo and SF sticking with their teams through the bowl games, even when they had new HC jobs elsewhere.