IIRC Manske is a '25 recruit and Smigiel is a '26 recruit. With regard to Smigiel, I'm glad to see us get in on these elite kids so early, even with Dayton in the mix.I didn't think Manske looked that great. And I agree with you Northwood
IIRC Manske is a '25 recruit and Smigiel is a '26 recruit. With regard to Smigiel, I'm glad to see us get in on these elite kids so early, even with Dayton in the mix.I didn't think Manske looked that great. And I agree with you Northwood
Every year, all the time. Grinders, world class and originalIIRC Manske is a '25 recruit and Smigiel is a '26 recruit. With regard to Smigiel, I'm glad to see us get in on these elite kids so early, even with Dayton in the mix.
And he gets some funny flat footed stuff sometimes. He sees windows come open quick and will zip it in a quick window though Throws nice leading balls that let receivers run after the catch. Even though the release is odd, he didn't seemed to have a big wind back waiting for a strip sack like TMagic or HH. Kid seems to have some moxie because he made some confident throws into tight windows.Now for my serious post. Watching his film, accurate quick release. However, does anyone else notice that he has a very low release point on the ball? I am curious how that will play in college.
I thought I noticed a little funky release. Hard to tell on my phoneDamn....he's a sophomore and to him threading balls in such tight windows is impressive.
Definitely an odd release for sure. Almost throws the ball like a catcher in baseball. In fact, I'd bet on the fact he was a baseball player his whole life.
Very true. A funky throwing motion doesn't always equate to inaccuracy. It's truly about the totality of the mechanics. That "funky" motion has some very desirable traits (short, compact motion, quick release).A couple of QBs who played baseball are doing all right in the Pros.
My concern in my post was not about inaccuracy. I am more worried about the low release point. May be ok in HS when the average DL is maybe 6 1 or 6 2. In college where DL are 6 4 or 6 5. Does it get knocked down? That is my concern.Very true. A funky throwing motion doesn't always equate to inaccuracy. It's truly about the totality of the mechanics. That "funky" motion has some very desirable traits (short, compact motion, quick release).
Mahomes and Brady were both baseball stars, but they had strong mechanics coming out of high school and only honed those skills even more once turning pro.
It will be interesting to see how he develops mechanically as he gets stronger.
Kid is already 6'5, so less of a concern throwing from the ear as opposed to a 6'1 QB.My concern in my post was not about inaccuracy. I am more worried about the low release point. May be ok in HS when the average DL is maybe 6 1 or 6 2. In college where DL are 6 4 or 6 5. Does it get knocked down? That is my concern.
Fair point.Kid is already 6'5, so less of a concern throwing from the ear as opposed to a 6'1 QB.
HH is 6’4” with the release point of a 5’5” QB with technique.Kid is already 6'5, so less of a concern throwing from the ear as opposed to a 6'1 QB.
HH is a different breed for many reasons. A true anomaly. The Kent Tekulve of football.HH is 6’4” with the release point of a 5’5” QB with technique.