They were close but I think I was in the sweet spot where MC missed me and GnR hit me. I always think of Shout at the Devil as the album that made Crue a force and I was too young for that to really hit me. I was in 6th Grade when Appetite came out and it (along with Hysteria) are the albums I think of when I think of '80s rock. Chuck Klosterman is one of my guilty pleasure authors and he's always writing about how early Crue was transformative for him as a kid. I'm guessing he's 5 or 6 years older than me so I suppose that makes sense.
Yeah, well I was 21 when Appetite came out and 19 when Theater came out. The years blended together quite a bit back then.