Yep, Frazier and Suh were jobbed.
Yep. Name me any other Heisman winner who was named MVP of three consecutive National Title games - including one his team lost. I'll wait.
| RUSH YDS | RUSH TD | RCV YDS | RCV TD | PASS YDS | PASS TD | TOTAL YDS | TOTAL TD |
Eddie George | 1927 | 24 | 417 | 1 | -- | -- | 2344 | 25 |
Tommie Frazier | 604 | 14 | -- | -- | 1362 | 17 | 1966 | 31 |
The only superior thing Eddie George did over Frazier was rack up +350 more yards. Going over 2000 All-Purpose Yards for a season is pretty impressive but Frazier was arguably the better player all around.
Both players were in college from 1992-1995, so comparing Ohio State and Nebraska over that run is pretty simple. While the Heisman is an "individual award" we all know it is more often an award given to the best beauty pageant player on one of the best 2-3 teams in the nation.
Objectively, Ohio State was not at the level of Nebraska during the 90s. They were a solid team, but at least during the careers of George and Frazier, they managed to only be Big Ten Co-Champs (Wisconsin) once. Never even went to a Rose Bowl. In fact, during George's tenure, they lost 3 bowls (UGA, BAMA, TENN) and win a lone win over BYU. You can argue that Frazier also lost two bowls to FSU, but 1992 was within a stone's throw of a national title game (FSU almost edged out Alabama) and 1993 WAS a National Title game.
Meanwhile, Eddie and the Buckeyes were getting their licks in against the Fighting Mormons and losing to every Tom, Dick and Harry SEC School in the conference. If anything, Michigan was the premier 1990s Big Ten team with a shared titled in 1997 and a pair of Heismans for Desmond Howard and Charles Woodson.
| Ohio State | Nebraska |
1992 | 8-3-1. Big Ten runner up. Lost Citrus Bowl to Georgia | 9-3-0. Big 8 Champs. Lost Orange Bowl to FSU |
1993 | 10-1-1. Big Ten Co-Champs (Wisconsin). Won Holiday Bowl over BYU. | 11-1. Big 8 Champs. Lost Orange Bowl to FSU |
1994 | 9-4. Big Ten runner up. Lost Citrus Bowl to Alabama | 13-0. Big 8 Champs. National Champs over Miami in Orange Bowl |
1995 | 11-2. Big Ten runner up. Lost Citrus Bowl to Tennessee. | 12-0. Big 8 Champs. National Champs over Florida in Fiesta Bowl |