5 Year Member
I guarantee that if it were 16 there would be upsets. Also there would be teams that because of where they play would actually get a chance and would make some noise for example UCF and Boise. They may just make it deeper than you think. It would also give teams that had one bad game like OSU and MI this year the chance to redeem themselves.#1 vs #16...#2 vs #15...#3 vs #14...#4 vs #13...and so on.
Are those really games you want to watch? That kind of stuff happens throughout the regular season.
A 16-team playoff would take away the one thing that sets college football apart from any other sport – every week matters.