NEW POLL: Is Rhule the coach?

[1standten]

Nick Saban would be .250 with this dumpster fire.

You seriously think Nick would have stood by and let Whipple piss that game down his trousers? He would have been all up in his grille telling him he best fix his play calling asap or hit the team bus.

 

[EyeWilDyeRed]

Sadly he probably is.

 

[Red October]

Three of the all-time greats might disagree...but don't let stats stand in your way.

Nick Saban CFB record: 278-29-1
Nick Saban NFL record: 15-17

Urban Meyer CFB record: 187-32
Urban Meyer NFL record: 2-11

Steve Spurrier CFB record: 228-89-2
Steve Spurrier NFL record: 12-20

Nick Saban wasnt fired he quit and I believe Spurrier quit too. Meyer was fired after the infamous bar dance. Im sure you can dredge up all kinds of stats as proof of your position but it doesnt change the fact that Rhule was a loser and so was Mike Rhiley....in THE N F L and both were .500 coaches in the NCAA.

 

[1standten]

Nick Saban wasnt fired he quit and I believe Spurrier quit too. Meyer was fired after the infamous bar dance. Im sure you can dredge up all kinds of stats as proof of your position but it doesnt change the fact that Rhule was a loser and so was Mike Rhiley....in THE N F L and both were .500 coaches in the NCAA.

No, I was arguing your statement that coaching CFB and NFL are the same. Clearly to three all-time great CFB coaches they are different beasts. To which you said is "nonsense". Please don't try to walk that back:

Just so yall know, Matt Rhules NFL record and Mike Rileys are the same. Yussss saying all this garbage about the NFL being a different beast is nonsense, its played with the same ball on the same field with the same players. It counts.

 

[jmatlock]

I’d argue that with you, all day long, as I think Osborne is the greatest ever college football coach. Tom could have easily won more NC’s, easily. He also did what he did at Nebraska, which we are all seeing, is not easy. Saban, while a very good coach who gets it, does it with the best players at nearly every position, in an area where recruiting is more bountiful, and definitely easier. You can cal me bias, but that’s the truth. Just think, what if Tom was an Alabama guy? He’d have crushed it there, just like he did at Nebraska.

Bottom line Osborne DIDN’T win those National Championships, Saban CAN recruit, and the tiebreaker Switzer owned Osborne, pal.

 

[WestTexasHusker]

Tom could have easily won more NC’s, easily. He also did what he did at Nebraska, which we are all seeing, is not easy.

Umm…now come again on that?

 

[Husker In Oklahoma]

Bottom line Osborne DIDN’T win those National Championships, Saban CAN recruit, and the tiebreaker Switzer owned Osborne, pal.

So could Osborne. I’ll take him 10 out of 10 over Saban. Switzer beating Osborne in the 1970’s, was the norm. No one was beating Oklahoma then. After 1977, they were even.

 

[Husker In Oklahoma]

Umm…now come again on that?

1978, beat Missouri, 1981, beat Clemson, 1982, the Penn State fiasco, 1983, kick the point after, 1993, screwed against Florida State, and 1996, half the team sick against Texas. He was a few plays or calls, from winning 5 in a row.

 

[jmatlock]

So could Osborne. I’ll take him 10 out of 10 over Saban. Switzer beating Osborne in the 1970’s, was the norm. No one was beating Oklahoma then. After 1977, they were even.

Saban7 Osborne 3
Only scoreboard that counts
And Saban still counting ,pal.
Plus in 2007 he took over an Alabama team that hadn’t been relevant since 1992

 

[jmatlock]

1978, beat Missouri, 1981, beat Clemson, 1982, the Penn State fiasco, 1983, kick the point after, 1993, screwed against Florida State, and 1996, half the team sick against Texas. He was a few plays or calls, from winning 5 in a row.

Woulda coulda shoulda pal

 

[Husker In Oklahoma]

Saban7 Osborne 3
Only scoreboard that counts
And Saban still counting ,pal.
Plus in 2007 he took over an Alabama team that hadn’t been relevant since 1992

I’m aware, but just measuring on just titles, to me, is not the end all. More to it. I’m not arguing Saban successes. He’s had quite a run. I just think Osborne is better.

 

[Husker In Oklahoma]

Woulda coulda shoulda pal

Woulda coulda shouldas with everyone.

 

[jmatlock]

Woulda coulda shouldas with everyone.

Woulda shoulda dida with Saban
7 times pal!

 

[Red Said Ted]

Just so yall know, Matt Rhules NFL record and Mike Rileys are the same. Yussss saying all this garbage about the NFL being a different beast is nonsense, its played with the same ball on the same field with the same players. It counts.

Well that takes Urban Meyer off the list. I always thought he was a pretty good college football coach until he went 2-11 in the NFL.

 

[BigRedOhio]

Time for Trev to start getting results with less fancy talk. We want a winner at all reasonable cost.