I wish the New Herbie's arm was a bit meatier. Like Popeye. That forearm is NOT the forearm of a man who wrenches on tractors all day.
See below for my quick edit. Thickening his forearm up makes a big difference.
Old Herbie has the best ball security. New Herbie has a loose ball grip. But if you thicken his other arm, he at least looks like the kind of guy who will punch out your teeth if you take his football.
Look at New Herbie's shoulders, for crying out loud. You don't get a chest/shoulders like that and have a chicken forearm.