The biggest Crappie I ever caught(not the heaviest or weighing the most, just big) was this strange anomaly of a fish. I was about 15 and a couple of friends and me were going between strip pits and and fishing in these creeks along the way. One particularly large strip pit had this stream that flowed down to another strip pit and although the water was murky, I cast my line anyway and felt a slight tug, thinking I snagged some brush or whatever, I continued to reel my lure in with no resistance. I pulled my lure up out of the water, and this thing was as big as a dinner plate(the fins would have been sticking out well over the plate). I start laughing and my buddy comes over and he's like, "WOW!" I bet this thing didn't weigh more than a pound and a half, if that much. It was so thin, I wasn't even sure it was a Crappie, but we all decided, based on colorings and whatnot that it was. I put it back in the creek as we were just fishing C&R that morning.