• You do not need to register if you are not going to pay the yearly fee to post. If you register please click here or log in go to "settings" then "my account" then "User Upgrades" and you can renew.

Field Goals

We did not have a "choice" on the XP kick, the officiating staff just grossly misapplied the response to the penalty, pulling nonsense out of the nether.

I looked up application of the rule. Pretty straightforward, a defensive penalty against a team kicking an XP results in the opportunity for the requisite field position adjustment and to retry the kick, period. Of course if the kick was good, you would decline the penalty.

Teams don't get to choose how a penalty is mitigated, they only get to choose to accept or decline the penalty, which of course will be based on how the play actually went down. The only permissible mitigation for the penalty in this case, according to the rules, was half the distance and retry.

The clown show officiating crew basically took a point away from our score in exchange for 15 yards of field position, and if anyone on the officiating crew tried to tell the boss, he ignored them. Or maybe they just all went along with it because they didn't know better. I am admittedly having a difficult time understanding why the coaching staff didn't make noise. Or maybe they did, not like making noise against those clowns mattered much.
 
We did not have a "choice" on the XP kick, the officiating staff just grossly misapplied the response to the penalty, pulling nonsense out of the nether.

I looked up application of the rule. Pretty straightforward, a defensive penalty against a team kicking an XP results in the opportunity for the requisite field position adjustment and to retry the kick, period. Of course if the kick was good, you would decline the penalty.

Teams don't get to choose how a penalty is mitigated, they only get to choose to accept or decline the penalty, which of course will be based on how the play actually went down. The only permissible mitigation for the penalty in this case, according to the rules, was half the distance and retry.

The clown show officiating crew basically took a point away from our score in exchange for 15 yards of field position, and if anyone on the officiating crew tried to tell the boss, he ignored them. Or maybe they just all went along with it because they didn't know better. I am admittedly having a difficult time understanding why the coaching staff didn't make noise. Or maybe they did, not like making noise against those clowns mattered much.
I just watched that play again from my recording. It sure looked like the official communicated with Rhule and pointed twice toward midfield before announcing that the penalty would be assessed on the kickoff. The camera then showed Rhule shaking his head in agreement with the official standing by him. I think it's possible that Rhule decided to kick the ball from the 50 and not retry the kick.
 
From inside 40 yards Cunanan was 14-14 last year and is 2-2 this year. Career wise, he is 25 of 28 (had three misses at Charlotte as a Freshman), From 40-49 yards he is 2 of 4 over two seasons for us and was 5 of 7 at Charlotte (7 of 11 overall). Over 50, yes, he has not done well as he has been 1 for 5 for us and was 0 for 1 at Charlotte. But those are pretty tough. They showed on his over 50 miss yesterday that there were issues getting the ball down correctly, while they said it probably did get down, it may have thrown off his timing.

Yeah, it might be good to give Hohl a shot on the 50 plus, but I think it all depends on what our situation is. A 50 yarder is from a LoS at the 33, so I think we just have to put that in our math.

I guess I am glad that if he had a miss on an extra point (everyone misses one eventually) it was one that came when we had a pretty much insurmountable lead.
Cunanan has been a solid kicker. I think some are quick to forget the adventure we went through a few years ago where XPs and short FGs were white knucklers. He just doesn't have the accuracy when you start pushing into the 50 yard range. It'd be great if he could drain them from out there, but that's asking quite a bit.

I don't disagree about letting Hohl try the longer kicks. There are a number of schools that have had a long yardage specialist. He's made one from 54 yards before, so we know he has it in him. Beyond that, we are probably better off just going for it when we are still that far out.
 
I just watched that play again from my recording. It sure looked like the official communicated with Rhule and pointed twice toward midfield before announcing that the penalty would be assessed on the kickoff. The camera then showed Rhule shaking his head in agreement with the official standing by him. I think it's possible that Rhule decided to kick the ball from the 50 and not retry the kick.
Hopefully someone asks about it at the press conference so we can get clarification. I don't understand why we would not attempt the try again. A point is more important than a touchback on the KO, even if we are up by three possessions. I can't fathom Rhule opting to leave the point behind.
 
We never saw the roughing-the-snapper call, where you cannot hit a snapper while he is still down in his stance. That likely played a role in the whole sequence. Not sure why it was enforced on the kickoff.
Chose to enforce on the kickoff. Could have retried the PAT, but the one point wasn't crucial.
I had/have a real difficult issue with this decision.
Re-try the PAT. Better yet, take the yardage and go for 2 points.

Not because the points were needed this game but because it might be needed in another game. We didn't need the yardage on the KO ... we were punting it into the end zone as it was!
 
Last edited:
Hopefully someone asks about it at the press conference so we can get clarification. I don't understand why we would not attempt the try again. A point is more important than a touchback on the KO, even if we are up by three possessions. I can't fathom Rhule opting to leave the point behind.
I can't either, but he didn't appear to be upset. That play was odd in a sea of bad officiating.
 
I had/have a real difficult issue with this decision.
Re-try the PAT. Better yet, take the yardage and go for 2 points.

Not because the points were needed this game but because it might be needed in another game. We didn't need the yardage on the KO ... we were punting it into the end zone as it was!
Actually, Hohl was not coming close to the end zone when he kicked that direction. However, I, too, would want the ball at the 1.5 yard line to try again or go for two.
 
I had/have a real difficult issue with this decision.
Re-try the PAT. Better yet, take the yardage and go for 2 points.

Not because the points were needed this game but because it might be needed in another game. We didn't need the yardage on the KO ... we were punting it into the end zone as it was!
Rhule addressed this in his presser. He apparently was focusing on something else and didn't see the PAT. So he asked the ref if we made it, and ref said yes, so MR said we'll take it on the KO. Then MR saw 48 on the scoreboard and asked the ref again (too late) and ref said he missed the PAT.

Rhule took the blame for the "stupid decision," bit then said, based on Maryland's returns, he might have called for the same anyway. Trying to avoid a big return.
 
Rhule addressed this in his presser. He apparently was focusing on something else and didn't see the PAT. So he asked the ref if we made it, and ref said yes, so MR said we'll take it on the KO. Then MR saw 48 on the scoreboard and asked the ref again (too late) and ref said he missed the PAT.

Rhule took the blame for the "stupid decision," bit then said, based on Maryland's returns, he might have called for the same anyway. Trying to avoid a big return.
Thanks for confirming what it looked like during the game.
 


That’s the only penalty they are owning up to?

Tom Cruise What GIF
 

GET TICKETS





Back
Top