Born on the Fourth of July movie

[Hooked on Huskers]

Second time I watched it tonight. First time was way back in 1990's. I initially thought pure fiction but actually tonight, pretty close to real story .... Ron Kovic life. Born on the Fourth of July film was better than Platoon and Full Metal Jacket (IMO)

Anyway, Cruise is fabulous ....... his greatest performance.

Born on the Fourth of July (film) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[Red Dead Redemption]

No.

 

[NUinID]

Second time I watched it tonight. First time was way back in 1990's. I initially thought pure fiction but actually tonight, pretty close to real story .... Ron Kovic life. Born on the Fourth of July film was better than Platoon and Full Metal Jacket (IMO)

Anyway, Cruise is fabulous ....... his greatest performance.

Born on the Fourth of July (film) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

I am not sure how how you can say it is better or worse. It is completely different from either of the other 2 movies. Full Metal Jacket is almost 2 separate movies and Platoon is basically Oliver Stone's view of what he saw in the Vietnam War.

The only thing you can say about the movies is that they are all anti war movies.

 

[Hooked on Huskers]

I am not sure how how you can say it is better or worse. It is completely different from either of the other 2 movies. Full Metal Jacket is almost 2 separate movies and Platoon is basically Oliver Stone's view of what he saw in the Vietnam War.

The only thing you can say about the movies is that they are all anti war movies.

Of course different plot but I liked true stories. That is why Born on the 4th is a best vs. Platoon & Full Metal.

Top 10 reviewers. All capture the horrors and brutalities of the Vietnam War. I suppose anti war movies ....

• Born on the Fourth of July
• Apocalypse Now
• Good Morning, Vietnam
• Platoon
• Full Metal Jacket
• We Were Soldiers (I never watched it)
• Coming Home (I never watched it)
• Casualties of War (I never watched it)
• Hamburger Hill (I never watched it)
• The Deer Hunter (I never watched it)

BTW, Good Morning Vietnam was loosely based on real experiences (Adrian Cronauer)

 

[HUSKER HOT SAUCE]

Of course different plot but I liked true stories. That is why Born on the 4th is a best vs. Platoon & Full Metal.

Top 10 reviewers. All capture the horrors and brutalities of the Vietnam War. I suppose anti war movies ....

• Born on the Fourth of July
• Apocalypse Now
• Good Morning, Vietnam
• Platoon
• Full Metal Jacket
• We Were Soldiers (I never watched it)
• Coming Home (I never watched it)
• Casualties of War (I never watched it)
• Hamburger Hill (I never watched it)
• The Deer Hunter (I never watched it)

BTW, Good Morning Vietnam was loosely based on real experiences (Adrian Cronauer)

You've never watched the bolded movie? DUDE! It's Iconic. Watch it, if you don't like that movie, I honestly don't know what to tell you.

 

[Hooked on Huskers]

You've never watched the bolded movie? DUDE! It's Iconic. Watch it, if you don't like that movie, I honestly don't know what to tell you.

Okay ..... I will watch Deer Hunter movie via Prime Video. Though I don't like Christopher Walken .....

I assume fiction, right?

 

[HUSKER HOT SAUCE]

Okay ..... I will watch Deer Hunter movie via Prime Video. Though I don't like Christopher Walken .....

I assume fiction, right?

Just watch it, don't assume anything.

 

[CO4NU]

"Letters from Iwo Jima" (Clint Eastwood movie) is very good.

Also a very good book.

 

[KleinTxHusker]

Of course different plot but I liked true stories. That is why Born on the 4th is a best vs. Platoon & Full Metal.

Top 10 reviewers. All capture the horrors and brutalities of the Vietnam War. I suppose anti war movies ....

• Born on the Fourth of July
• Apocalypse Now
• Good Morning, Vietnam
• Platoon
• Full Metal Jacket
• We Were Soldiers (I never watched it)
• Coming Home (I never watched it)
• Casualties of War (I never watched it)
• Hamburger Hill (I never watched it)
• The Deer Hunter (I never watched it)

BTW, Good Morning Vietnam was loosely based on real experiences (Adrian Cronauer)

I really liked Born on the Fourth of July, because it was a true story and also reflected many of the problems of soldiers who returned; things @Pops has talked about. Also, understand my cousin who saw heavy combat, but was not wounded (but close calls) and had civilian adjustment issues.

I highlighted those that I have seen. "We Were Solders" is a true story, and from a movie perspective is close to the battle scenes of "Saving Private Ryan." I cannot remember if it was based on a book I had read, or if it was an essay.

I also saw "A Bright and Shining Lie" which apparently was a made for TV; I liked the book, interestingly, Daniel Ellsberg & David Halberstam asked that their names not be used in the movie (I wondered why their "characters" were combined and had a different name; I knew who they were from the book). Reading the book was the first time I had heard of "ArmaLite" (Ellsberg would grab an "ArmaLite" and a Jeep and drive around 1962 Vietnam),

A Bright Shining Lie (film) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

I note you left off "The Green Berets," I saw that one, too...

 

[Hooked on Huskers]

I really liked Born on the Fourth of July, because it was a true story and also reflected many of the problems of soldiers who returned; things @Pops has talked about. Also, understand my cousin who saw heavy combat, but was not wounded (but close calls) and had civilian adjustment issues .......
.
....... I note you left off "The Green Berets," I saw that one, too...

My brother-in-law, Vietnam vet. Army I think. Wounded, metal plate replacement in his skull. Apparently no problem with his civilian adjustment.

I watched Green Berets movie a long long time ago. Starring John Wayne.

 

[Pops]

Never seen it nor any war movie

 

[Woodhead]

I really liked Born on the Fourth of July, because it was a true story and also reflected many of the problems of soldiers who returned; things @Pops has talked about. Also, understand my cousin who saw heavy combat, but was not wounded (but close calls) and had civilian adjustment issues.

I highlighted those that I have seen. "We Were Solders" is a true story, and from a movie perspective is close to the battle scenes of "Saving Private Ryan." I cannot remember if it was based on a book I had read, or if it was an essay.

I also saw "A Bright and Shining Lie" which apparently was a made for TV; I liked the book, interestingly, Daniel Ellsberg & David Halberstam asked that their names not be used in the movie (I wondered why their "characters" were combined and had a different name; I knew who they were from the book). Reading the book was the first time I had heard of "ArmaLite" (Ellsberg would grab an "ArmaLite" and a Jeep and drive around 1962 Vietnam),

A Bright Shining Lie (film) - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

I note you left off "The Green Berets," I saw that one, too...

We Were Soldiers is based on a book written by the (at the time) Commanding Officer of the unit whom first fought a significant battle with the North Vietnamese and an AP writer there at that battle. It was fairly decent in its treatment of reality save for the third and final day when the culmination was Hollywood fantasy.
It is a superb book, a decent movie, and a very important lesson in what can happen when trying to fight a "limited war". It is the soldier whom pays for those limits.