I checked what I could find online, and he was recruited and signed to a baseball scholarship, but the coach told him he could play football, and it was the baseball coaches who told the football coaches to take a look at him after the '94 Orange Bowl when they saw him punting 50-yard punts while screwing around. Even then he had to go on scholarship for football in '94 since he was playing football. Osborne was hoping to keep him for '95, but the Angels and millions of dollars got in the way of that plan.I think you are likely correct. Now my understanding of NCAA rules is any male two/multi sport athlete will have to be counted as a Football Scholarship if Football is one of them. The only thing I am not sure about is if Basketball is one of them, how that would fit in. I would assume Track & Basketball would count against Basketball. Of course, I think it only becomes a hit when they actually play Football. Of course, I suspect once they go on Football Scholarship, a Baseball (or Track or...) Scholarship would be freed up.
I really would like to know more about the high school stories that I've heard through the grapevine. In those pre-internet days you never knew what was just a good story versus what really happened, but he did play football, baseball, hockey, and run track in high school, and Jamestown did win the state tournament in basketball his senior year, so it's all plausible.