Get HuskerMax™ on your iPhone. Click here for details. Get tickets for all home and away games here.
Results 1 to 13 of 13

Thread: Elliot Porter snubbed by LSU

Hybrid View

  1. #1

    Elliot Porter snubbed by LSU

    Don't follow recruiting much, but it looks like an O-line guy we offered but who went with LSU was snubbed on moving in day!

    With Bo's connection to LSU and the fact we just had an O-lineman defect to Kansas, would this perhaps be a good fit?

    http://rivals.yahoo.com/ncaa/footbal...n=ncaaf-260264

  2. #2
    Guest

    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Lincoln, NE
    Posts
    1,879
    Quote Originally Posted by Tunnelwalk View Post
    Don't follow recruiting much, but it looks like an O-line guy we offered but who went with LSU was snubbed on moving in day!

    With Bo's connection to LSU and the fact we just had an O-lineman defect to Kansas, would this perhaps be a good fit?

    http://rivals.yahoo.com/ncaa/footbal...n=ncaaf-260264
    OuCh!!!

  3. #3
    Get behind the Mule!
    FeelLikeAStranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Hardscratch Springs
    Posts
    28,585
    Not a good plan for ol' Lester there...

    We don't have room for another signee. If Heard doesn't make it, we are dead even on schollies for fall by my count after we added Baptiste and lost Harper.
    "Just because somebody's a talented guy or he's right for a lot of people
    doesn't mean he's right for us here at Nebraska." -Bo Pelini, 2/3/10


  4. #4
    Guest

    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Nova Scotia
    Posts
    718
    Another take on Miles and mentions a few other coaches. Pretty tough to sit in a prospective recruit's living room and explain this to Mom and Dad.

    "At LSU, Les Miles went grim reaper this year on three different someones -- none more appallingly than Elliott Porter. Porter is a freshman offensive lineman from Waggaman, La., who signed with LSU in February, qualified academically, reported to summer school in June and started taking classes. After two months as a member of the LSU football family, Porter was summoned last week from his dorm room to Les Miles' office to hear that he wasn't part of the family anymore. Sorry, son. You're out. The NCAA allows a team to add 25 scholarship freshmen, and LSU had gone over that limit. Someone had to go, and that someone was Elliott Porter. "

    from http://www.cbssports.com/collegefoot..._photo_content

  5. #5
    All Legend
    BuffSurveyor's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Down The Road
    Posts
    16,409
    I feel for this kid.

    Don't know what I would do if I were in his position. But I know on thing for sure, I would consider going elsewhere.
    It's a great day to be a Husker Fan!
    Live By The Code!
    (28-13-3) GATA If you see a skunk in the middle of the road, do you run it over or let it live? That is a quandary?

  6. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by BuffSurveyor View Post
    I feel for this kid.

    Don't know what I would do if I were in his position. But I know on thing for sure, I would consider going elsewhere.
    A gray shirt should never come as a surprise...

    Essentially if the kid goes elsewhere, he has to sit out a season as a transfer unless the NCAA makes an exception on appeal; that is the biggest problem.

    I do not agree that coaches should not be allowed to oversign. Some of the solutions are due to problems with NCAA rules and the difficulty in knowing who will qualify and if/when they will get through the clearinghouse.

  7. #7
    Moderator

    Join Date
    Nov 1999
    Location
    Clearwater, Florida
    Posts
    63,826
    Quote Originally Posted by BuffSurveyor View Post
    I feel for this kid.

    Don't know what I would do if I were in his position. But I know on thing for sure, I would consider going elsewhere.
    I hear ya BuffSurveyor. I'm with you on Porter going somewhere else.

  8. #8
    Guest

    Join Date
    Dec 1999
    Location
    Kansas City, MO
    Posts
    21,614
    That is a tough situation for both the player and the coach. Due to things beyond the coaches control if grades and NCAA clearinghouse issues I can see wjy coaches over sign. But if a coach is going to IMO he better make sure that the recruits that could be left out know in advance before accepting a LOI from them. Then if the recruit wants to take the chance so be it, but if they do not they have a chance to see what is still availble to them in Febuary.

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by HUSKER 4 EVER View Post
    That is a tough situation for both the player and the coach. Due to things beyond the coaches control if grades and NCAA clearinghouse issues I can see wjy coaches over sign. But if a coach is going to IMO he better make sure that the recruits that could be left out know in advance before accepting a LOI from them. Then if the recruit wants to take the chance so be it, but if they do not they have a chance to see what is still availble to them in Febuary.
    What was really bad is the kid qualified, came to summer school to work out and enroll... this makes him a transfer... meaning he has to sit out a year (unless NCAA says he can play elsewhere)... At some point

    The free option aspect of LOIs; scholarships, etc. are all in favor of the schools. In the past most coaches have not abused this, but if it starts happening too often, the whole process will be changed... That might be good, but history has been to make things worse for the players. Part of the reason coaches are doing this is less scholarships and tighter admission requirements. I think it is quite plausible that the NCAA has gone too far in both points.

  10. #10
    Moderator
    Red Dawn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Gotham City
    Posts
    10,928
    I do not believe he will have any issues going to another school - if you have a little free time, go here for more info on this issue www.oversigning.com

  11. #11
    Moderator
    BornToBeRed's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Kansas City, MO
    Posts
    14,590
    Quote Originally Posted by Red Dawn View Post
    I do not believe he will have any issues going to another school - if you have a little free time, go here for more info on this issue www.oversigning.com
    I was pointed to that sight a while back, great read. They really do their homework. Suggested to anyone who follows recruiting closely.

  12. #12
    I would hope that we stay to the undersigned model...

    You cannot have a good walk-on program without awarding scholarships to walk-ons. I'd argue we should award 3 or 4 per year.

    Here is why I think the NCAA regs have unintentionally contributed to the problem... they should allow much more in the way of summer programs/camps for evaluating talent (I noticed virtually every school had theirs at the same week... Is this per NCAA regs?)

    6. Oversigning doesn't create a competitive advantage so what's the big deal.

    This couldn't be any further from the truth, especially within the last several years. Over the last several years the ability for coaches to evaluate players has decreased; the NCAA continues to decrease the amount of contact coaches can have with players (mainly out of fear of recruiting violations) which is making it hard for them to evaluate talent. In addition, the NCAA continues to place more and more restrictions on the amount of time coaches can spend with players during spring and fall training camps and during the off season. The net result is college football has become less about developing talent and more about mining for the next "sure thing" 5 star recruit.

    When you oversign you have access to more opportunities to find that "sure thing" whether it be from landing a 5 star recruit or taking a chance on a borderline guy who turns out to be a stud. It's a numbers game and obviously, given that most of the top tier schools can attract top tier talent, the more of it that you can go through to find the ones you really want the better you will be.

    Nick Saban and Les Miles have used oversigning as the backbone of building National Championship teams over the last decade. If you look at the chart below and look at the number of players signed by Saban (who had the highest average) and Tressel (who had the lowest average), in the years that Saban was in college football he signed roughly 193 recruits; Tressel signed roughly 142 in those same years. That is a difference of 51 recruiting opportunities over the same period of time. Any change there might be a couple more good players in that list of 51? If the difference were 5-10 I don't think we could point at this being an issue, but 51?
    Also... Tressel at 142 signees vs. Miles at193... I always liked Tressel...

  13. #13
    Get behind the Mule!
    FeelLikeAStranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Hardscratch Springs
    Posts
    28,585
    Quote Originally Posted by KleinTxHusker View Post
    I would hope that we stay to the undersigned model...
    Well, we technically oversigned big this past year, starting out with a recruiting budget of something like 12 scholarships before fall camp and ending up with 22-23 signees, but some attrition was definitely expected in year 2.

    We will find ourselves in a similar position next year with 12 JR's on the roster and no scholarships to speak of to give to walk-ons to normalize that number somewhat. We are sitting at +1 right now with Heard not making it. We can give that to a SR walk-on this year, but that's all we have barring any unforseen defections at this point.


    Bo has done a fantastic job of rebuilding and managing the roster and position groups, but in the strict "oversigning" definition used by that website, he's also guilty of oversigning due to the roster mess he was left with....certainly not anywhere close to the extent that Nutt or Miles have in recent years. Our staff is very picky about the academic side of things, it seems, so we will not sign many players that are in danger of NQ. I don't feel that Bo has "oversigned" at all, but depending on what definition you go by, that's up for debate.
    "Just because somebody's a talented guy or he's right for a lot of people
    doesn't mean he's right for us here at Nebraska." -Bo Pelini, 2/3/10








Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •