If a scholarship is dogging it as N2FL says ( not showing up or late for meetings, poor class attendance or lack of effort at any time) I agree the scholarship should be pulled as the player is not earning ( according to the coach) his scholarship.
N2FL ...do you have any information that any of these players were dogging it and deserve to lose their scholarship? If not It's my opinion that none of the players mentioned by you in your posts should have the worth of their contribtition to the team questioned in any way.
If Ron Brown says Mr. Gilleylen is the kind of kid "you go to war with" and holds him up as an example of an ultimate player that's good enough for me. I will continue to have that opinion of him and the others you claim didn't earn their scholarship until the coaches tell me otherwise.